Category Archives/Archivos de la categoría: Articles

The Criminal Process

This is a portion of a letter I sent to an attorney in Colombia and Mexico that may be of interest to those of you unfamiliar with the federal criminal process. My explanation of the process begins after the defendant’s attorney receives the evidence from the government and engages in plea negotiations with the prosecutor:

After […]

Posted in Articles | Comments Off on The Criminal Process

Uncle Sam Is No Sissy

Once there was a fellow who was arrested for three kilos of cocaine in his house in the 70’s when the “tough on crime” drug laws were in vogue. Every politician wanted to be tougher than the next. Now, this quantity would have resulted in a defendant getting 5 years at most, maybe seven if […]

Posted in Articles | Comments Off on Uncle Sam Is No Sissy

Extradition Complaints

A reader complained of his extradition saying he should not have been extradited and wanted to bring that up to the Federal hearing his case. Waste of time. The United States doesn’t care how it gets you. The U.S. government has kidnapped people and it is ok. The rule of law in the U.S. is […]

Posted in Articles | Comments Off on Extradition Complaints

Illegal Searches in Foreign Countries

A reader complained of an illegal search in his home country of Colombia.  He wants to know what he can do about it in the United States. Nothing. If you are not a U.S. citizen and you suffer an illegal search in your own country, you do not have the protection to be free from […]

Posted in Articles | Comments Off on Illegal Searches in Foreign Countries

Out of State Lawyers

I get a lot of complaints about this: out of State lawyers not visiting their clients. My response: It is your own fault. If I had a case in Bogota, I would not get a lawyer from Cali or vice versa. If I had a case in New York, I would not get a lawyer from […]

Posted in Articles | Comments Off on Out of State Lawyers

U.S. Addresses Extradition

Dimitrios Skaftouros (“Skaftouros”) was wanted in Greece on murder charges. A Magistrate Judge of the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York certified him as extraditable, but the decision was overturned by a District Court judge who denied the extradition.

The Government appealed and the Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit […]

Posted in Articles | Comments Off on U.S. Addresses Extradition

Acceptance of Responsibility

The guidelines are a sentencing scheme by which levels are accorded to different factors such as the nature of the crime, the amount of drugs or money involved in the crime, the role played by the defendant in the crime, and whether he “accepted responsibility” which is looked upon favorably. Each factor determines levels and […]

Posted in Articles | Comments Off on Acceptance of Responsibility

Taking a Case to Trial after the Client has Proffered

Taking a case to trial after the client has “proffered” (spoken to the prosecutor) is difficult. Most proffer agreements have a clause permitting the government to introduce the defendant’s proffer statements to rebut evidence offered or elicited, or factual assertions made by, the defense. In United States v. Barrow, 400 F.3d 109 (2d Cir. 2005), […]

Posted in Articles | Comments Off on Taking a Case to Trial after the Client has Proffered

The Phones Have Ears: Communications through a prison monitored phone

In United States v. Rodriguez, No. 10-2724-cr (2d Cir. August 25, 2011), a defendant, while detained at the MDC in New York, called his sister and asked her to tell their brother to contact defendant’s attorney so that they could discuss whether he should “cop out” before being indicted. He indicated that the […]

Posted in Articles | Comments Off on The Phones Have Ears: Communications through a prison monitored phone

Sentencing: Who has the burden?

United States v. Archer, No. 10-4684-cr (2d Cir. September 20, 2011), a case involving fraud by an attorney, brought up a particularly interesting discussion of the procedures for sentencing issues upon returning a case to the trial court for reconsideration of sentence. The “consensus” among the other circuits is “where the government knew […]

Posted in Articles | Comments Off on Sentencing: Who has the burden?

Withdrawal from the Conspiracy

In United States v. Leslie,  (2d Cir.October 3, 2011) the court rejected the argument that a defendant’s incarceration stannding alone, should be treated as a withdrawal from the conspiracy for sentencing purposes.

Defendant was serving a bank fraud sentence in 2005, but during his incarceration others continued the scheme. In 2009, Leslie was transferred to federal […]

Posted in Articles | Comments Off on Withdrawal from the Conspiracy

Size Matters

The Wisdom of Crowds: Why the Many Are Smarter Than the Few is a book written by James Surowiecki about group thinking that, he argues, makes for better decision-making than decisions made by any single member.

The example he uses is a true story of a crowd at a county fair that accurately guessed […]

Posted in Articles | Comments Off on Size Matters

Application of U.S. laws outside U.S.

The Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit in the recent case of United States vs. Al Kassar set forth legal rules that extradited defendants and their lawyers should find useful.

The defendants in that case argued that U.S. courts had no right to prosecute them because their conduct had little or no connection […]

Posted in Articles | Comments Off on Application of U.S. laws outside U.S.

Solitary Confinement is Torture

Taken from an article in the New York Times, November 5, 2011 written by Sarah Shourd, a writer who was imprisoned in Iran, entitled “Torture by Solitude.”

“After two months with next to no human contact, my mind began to slip. Some days, I heard phantom footsteps coming down the hall. I spent large portions of […]

Posted in Articles | Comments Off on Solitary Confinement is Torture

Q and A

After an extradited defendant arrives in the USA, how much time can pass before the court decides his case?

It could be months or even years, depending on what the defendant wants to do. If he wants to cooperate with the United States government then he will stay there for as long as his cooperation takes. […]

Posted in Articles | Comments Off on Q and A

A Dirty Little Secret

The best lawyer in the criminal process is not necessarily the one who always wins because that is impossible. The best lawyer is the one who lets the prosecutor know that even though the prosecutor could win, it will take him all fifteen bloody rounds to do so, and oftentimes it is not worth it. […]

Posted in Articles | Comments Off on A Dirty Little Secret

Jury Trials And Fear

The judge tells a jury how to decide a case, and the jury obeys. That is why it is wrong to suggest that because someone is a Colombian and the case involves drugs, the Colombian is going to be convicted. It is not true. The jury weighs the evidence, and where the evidence is sufficient, […]

Posted in Articles | Comments Off on Jury Trials And Fear

Sentencing: Ordering Minutes

Whenever possible, it is a good idea to order sentencing minutes of co-defendants. Not only will you know what your judge thinks of the crime, but you might get an idea of what he thinks of sentencing in general.

I was in front of Judge Patterson of the Southern District of New York who is a […]

Posted in Articles | Comments Off on Sentencing: Ordering Minutes

U.S. Accused of Working with Cartel

The case is intriguing. Motion papers allege that the DEA struck a deal with members of a Mexican cartel to allow it to ply their trade so long as they provided information to the DEA about other cartels. The idea has some validity. The motion relies in part on a former DEA chief that promoted […]

Posted in Articles | Comments Off on U.S. Accused of Working with Cartel

The Day the Government Blinked

About seventeen months ago, a Colombian defendant, instead of waiting to be extradited to the United States, surrendered to federal authorities. The defendant, however, was not coming to the United States to plead guilty to narco-trafficking charges as the government hoped. The government threatened him with trial. The prosecutors said they had paramilitary “cooperators” (the […]

Posted in Articles | Comments Off on The Day the Government Blinked